Nonfiction by Dorothy Lazard, reviewed by Jo Ann Zimmerman
BEHIND THE DESK AT THE MAIN: A LIBRARIAN’S MEMOIR (Heyday Books)
Some years back, when our youngest headed off to college, my husband and I did the downsize thing, trading in our big stone house with five bedrooms on three floors for a little brick model in the heart of a nearby neighborhood. On our first Halloween here, a young mom marched up to our door with a wee bumble bee in tow. The little bee’s antennae shook as she hopped up and down, shouting, “Mom, look! They get to live right across from THE LIBRARY!”
My heart soared. I have loved libraries since I was a wee bee myself. Even more than my many outstanding teachers, Miss Ada, the librarian at our local library, is responsible for my addiction to books; she hooked me with her story time reading of The Phantom Tollbooth when I was eight. Fifteen years later I became a reading teacher and I’ve been hawking wares in the word market ever since.
Dorothy Lazard is that kind of librarian. Her new book Behind the Desk at the Main: A Librarian’s Memoir is a love letter to libraries — as well as a warning of their present perils. The memoir chronicles her experiences in various positions at the main branch in Oakland, California; each chapter describes her adventures and offers insightful commentary on how they illustrate our evolving relationship with libraries across America. Incorporating quotes from a wide spectrum of cultural icons — from Frank Zappa to Walter Cronkite — the book also reveals how widely libraries are revered.
Lazard, who served as a public librarian for more than 20 years, writes, “The public library is our country’s last truly democratic institution. It welcomes at no cost any and all regardless of their social or economic status, race, cultural background, gender, citizenship status, physical ability, literacy, or age.” (p.7) She suggests that libraries are and always have been radical institutions; the idea of giving common people access to any and all information would be thought dangerous in many countries, and unaffordable in others.
If you want to get laid, go to college. If you want an education, go to the library.
—Frank Zappa
In the chapter titled “A Second Start,” Lazard relates a story of being on reference desk duty shortly before closing time on August 28, 2008. It was the forty-fifth anniversary of Dr. King’s “I have a Dream” speech, and Lazard was listening to the Democratic National Convention online while doing some paperwork. As Barack Obama began to speak, a middle-aged Black man walked up to the desk. She recognized him as Mr. James, a patron who came to the library every Thursday to work with a woman who tutored him in the Second Start literacy program. Together they listened with pride as Obama spoke.
Lazard shares that she thought then how dangerous it would have been for Mr. James to try to learn to read 150 years ago, or to sit beside a white woman in public when he was a boy in the 1950s. While proud and hopeful about the possibility of electing the first Black president, she also wondered what Obama would do for people like Mr. James, who had worked hard, raised families, paid taxes, but never had the opportunity to get a good education. Her job at the library brought her in contact with many who struggled with literacy, and thus with applying to college, getting good jobs, and other stepping stones to a better life.
Whatever the cost of our libraries, the price is cheap compared to that of an ignorant nation.
—Walter Cronkite
As you may recall, months after Obama’s historic election, the Great Recession hit. While the new president saved the banks and other entities considered “too big to fail,” ordinary citizens suffered job loss, soaring rents, and homelessness. Funding for public institutions such as parks, schools, and libraries was slashed. Lazard writes, “The public library in the municipal ecosystem is far down on the food chain.” (p. 100). However, she explains that the need for library services remains — and often expands — in harsh economic times because people who are struggling financially rely on community resources, libraries especially, for everything from internet access to free tax prep services, in addition to accessing ebooks and streaming movies at no cost. The author is not shy about her opinion of bailing out banks while allowing communities of color to suffer: “A budget is a moral document.” (p. 102)
Don’t join the book burners. Don’t think you’re going to conceal faults by concealing evidence that they ever existed. Don’t be afraid to go in your library and read every book.
—Dwight D. Eisenhower
Behind the Desk at the Main also reminds us that the politicization of libraries is nothing new. For many years during Jim Crow, BIPOC were denied access to American public libraries, and women were exploited as low-cost labor from the beginning. The present moment, however, sees libraries compromised by campaigns against intellectual freedom. And the numbers Lazard shares are alarming: in 2024, the American Library Association found that 4240 unique titles were targeted for censorship; 72% of those challenges were organized by political groups and/or government institutions, such as state legislatures and school boards, and most were sponsored by right wing groups who spread conspiracy theories online. Lazard also cites information from PEN America, the writers’ advocacy group, that shows Texas and Florida ban the most books, but such efforts are nationwide, often led by Moms for Liberty and similar conservative groups. As Lazard remarks, “I find it ironic that a group that speaks of liberty wants to suppress someone else’s freedom to read.”
Especially today, it’s easy to suppose that the leap from justifying the removal of books about marginalized people to the removal of those people is a short one. We see this daily in cities across the country where immigration agents violently remove those who do not fit the Eurocentric narrative. Libraries, Lazard contends, are “a bulwark against these restrictive and repressive social and political forces.” (p. 128)
As a child, my number one best friend was the librarian in my grade school. I actually believed all those books belonged to her.
—Erma Bombeck
While many may consider libraries to be repositories of books curated by spinsters, my own neighborhood branch, like a lot of others, also offers patrons a “library of things.” In addition to books and magazines, I have borrowed knitting needles, museum passes, board games, and a mole grip (don’t ask). There are also regularly scheduled story hours, ESL classes, and author talks. And as Lazard details in the book’s appendix (100 Intriguing Reference Questions), librarians field many questions from their patrons, including: On what island was Robinson Crusoe marooned? How do you say “Oakland” in Pig Latin? And do you have any books about Hitler and “that Nazi thing”?
But public librarians today find themselves beset with requests to remove books and replace them with game consoles, computer labs, teen lounges, and event spaces. In recent years, the disappearance of books has led to another library loss that goes unnoticed by most — the exodus of librarians themselves: “As people leave the profession, libraries lose years of institutional memory and great models of public service.” (p. 187)
When Lazard began to imagine joining the ranks of her retired peers, she mused, “I knew the day was coming. How would I know when I was done? And how would it feel to be done?” (p. 189) But as she witnessed the role of urban public libraries like hers shift from meeting their communities’ needs for information to providing basic social services such as free lunches for kids, personal hygiene kits, and packets of socks and underwear, she wondered what had happened to the people and agencies that once met those needs. Beyond that, library staff were routinely harassed and threatened by mentally unstable patrons, and some had been assaulted, yet their concerns were dismissed. Ultimately, she accepted that she would have to find her own peace elsewhere.
The very existence of libraries affords the best evidence that we may yet have hope for the future of man.
—T.S. Eliot
Looking back on her long tenure behind the desk, the author concludes, “Retirement suits me fine.” (p. 199) Leaving the library allowed her to pursue other interests. Not surprisingly, one of the first projects she and her husband tackled was to build, fill, and register their own Little Free Library. Stocked with spy novels, cookbooks, and other treasures from her personal collection, Lazard was delighted when neighbors not only utilized her Free Library, but installed their own, noting, “The impulse to share books is a most commendable trait that builds community, inspires reading, and cultivates knowledge.” (p. 204)
Retirement also gave her time to complete some half-finished book manuscripts, including this one. If Behind the Desk at the Main: A Librarian’s Memoir saves one library, one librarian, or even one book, Lazard’s legacy of public service will live on.
* * *
Behind The Desk At The Main: A Librarian’s Memoir by Dorothy Lazard was published by Heyday Books on August 18, 2026.
Jo Ann Zimmerman is a lifelong educator, most recently on the faculty of the University of the Arts in Philadelphia, where she lives with her amazing husband and indifferent cat. She has written for the Adroit Journal, Rain Taxi Review, and Philadelphia Stories, among others.
Read more from Cleaver Magazine’s Book Reviews.



