A Writing Tip by Jen Schneider
LOST LIST AND FOUND

“With no thought of buying, the eye is sportive and generous;
it creates; it adorns; it enhances.”
—Virginia Woolf, Street Haunting: A London Adventure

I recently bought a secondhand book of other people’s discarded grocery lists. Titled Milk Eggs Vodka, Bill Keaggy’s compilation of “grocery lists lost and found” is a deliciously eccentric collection of consumers’ must-haves. Even at the price of $1, this purchase may seem perplexing to some. After all, who needs more to-do lists? 

I’d usually agree. Admittedly, I had ventured to the bookstore specifically to avoid to-do lists of my own. When I purchased the book, it wasn’t the lists themselves that caught my attention, but the stories they held. These lists were most certainly never intended as literature. They’d never be filed as poetic or even ripe with potential. In fact, it’s likely that many of the lists were never even intended to survive the trip to the store and their owner-authors never anticipated a life for their lists beyond the checkout register.

Still, I discovered something unexpected while not shopping. The combination of apricots, Yankee baseball cards (signed), and five-dollar bills with Bud Light inked across Lincoln’s profile made for interesting hypothesizing. The book’s playful mix of cursive, block letters, misspelled spaghetti, and exclamation marks did too. Scratch outs and (sometimes inaccurate) arithmetic, as well. From standards like milk (full fat?) and bread (Wonder only?) to less familiar items like suet cake, mince, and nappies—the lists are surprisingly perfect for inspiring dinner and poetry! 

At first, I flipped through the book, browsing but not shopping for much. Then, I started to linger on individual lists (and items) that caught my eye. And as I lingered, I began to feel inspired to create lists (some I’d even call poetry) of my own. I left not only with a new book in my tote but possible poem titles simmering in my head…

Baking soda as a frenemy
My love-hate relationship with Coke (not Pepsi)
Creakers not crackers

When I wandered into the bookstore (a maze of connected rooms and floors that creak of history), I was browsing, which is decidedly different from looking for something specific. Looking usually begins with some idea of what ought to be found. Browsing offers permission to be distracted. It’s easy to get lost in a bookstore, and, once lost, to find inspiration.

Kleenex – tall; Vodka, vanilla ice cream. Four lemons. Kotex Tampons. Snickers. 

Cross-outs. Additions. Unique fonts. Different writing utensils. 

I kept reading. Sure, I lost some unexpected minutes of my day, but I found much more, including much-needed creative energy. Scholars have written about wandering and browsing as one route to serendipitous discovery, something usefully encountered without having been specifically sought. A 2022 study in the Journal of Creativity looks at serendipity as a way of stimulating creative thought. Browsing lets attention spread out whereas a list gives it somewhere to land. Psychologists say one of the functions of list-making is cognitive offloading. A 2025 review in Nature Reviews Psychology uses the shopping list as an example; putting information somewhere outside the mind reduces the amount we have to keep active in memory. When a page (sticky note or torn sheet of paper) is tasked with remembering the can of chickpeas, five limes, fresh basil, and ZUCCHINI!!! (to bake), it also frees up the mind for something else. Similarly, browsing keeps that mind open—and that’s often when (and sometimes where) poetry is best found. 

Possibly four lemons. Possibly bratwurst, prune juice, or (and??) Desitin cream.

Just as walking into a grocery store without a list can yield a low need-to-purchase ratio, a blank page is often counterproductive when getting started on a new writing project. So, I encourage you to try a new way of browsing turned list-making (or list-making while browsing). Instead of beginning with a poem as the purpose, gift yourself an opportunity to be distracted. Write down ten titles from a random library shelf. Pick up seven out-of-date magazines. Wander into a local bookstore but don’t tell yourself what to look for. Then, when ready, unpack what you wrote and see what story is waiting. Consider which of your finds feel least ordinary. Milk did not hold my attention for longer than the length of a carton. Bread behaved itself and failed to release new Wonder. Four lemons stumped me. Five limes did too. Why four? Why five? It’s hard to know. Which is probably why it’s fun to think about them.

When Dr. Seuss wrote Oh, the Places You’ll Go!, I bet he wasn’t thinking about stories on old supermarket lists. But by not going much of anywhere, other than opening a book of abandoned grocery lists in a local store I love, I ended up with ideas and newfound energy for new poems. 

So, this “tip” is not really to turn a list into a poem. Or to browse without any reason. Instead, it’s to let your mind wander with intention and then see where it lands and what it lands upon. Maybe you’ll make a list; maybe you’ll return home with a new idea in hand. 

I wish you the gift of getting lost in an unexpected aisle (or browsing some lists here: grocerylists.org) and finding inspiration you didn’t realize you were looking for. 

PS: If you’re in Philly, you might take that walk locally through the Chestnut Hill bookstore tour (see Karen Rile’s amazing post). Otherwise, you could try exploring your own local bookstores—new and used—as well as thrift stores, record stores, museums, and libraries.


Jen Schneider is a community college educator who lives, works, and writes in small spaces in and around Philadelphia. She served as the 2022 Montgomery County (PA) Poet Laureate.

 

Read more from Cleaver’s Writing Tips.

Join our other 6,526 subscribers!

Use this form to receive a free subscription to our quarterly literary magazine. You'll also receive occasional newsletters with tips on writing and publishing and info about our seasonal writing workshops.